Who carries the cost when a disciplinary case drags on for years, then the person facing it resigns?

Parliament’s justice committee raised that question on 18 November, calling for legislative changes concerning magistrates who leave office during disciplinary proceedings.

The salary bill behind the debate

In its statement, the committee cited more than R7.36 million paid during the suspension of Bloemfontein regional magistrate LT Mkansi. It said payments continued for seven months after his criminal conviction and sentence.

It separately put the cost of K Bodlani’s provisional suspension at approximately R8 million over more than five years before her resignation. These are the committee’s figures, not a new SBL audit.

A call for change, not a new law

The committee welcomed commitments to notify the Legal Practice Council about resignations during active proceedings and keep a database to prevent subsequent acting judicial appointments. It also cited discussions on recovering suspension pay where guilt is ultimately established.

The announcement does not establish that new legislation has passed or that money has been recovered.

The question worth following

The public-interest test is whether a reform can deliver timely, fair decisions, rather than simply changing the exit paperwork. Suspension should not be treated as proof of misconduct. Equally, a resignation should not be reported as proof that unresolved allegations were either established or cleared.

What matters next is the detail: proposed amendments, safeguards for those facing proceedings and evidence of completed accountability measures.